Stuck for ideas for your Chemistry IA? Here is a list of 50 ideas that should hopefully inspire you to come up with an excellent IA of your own. Carl is a highly experienced Chemistry tutor who is available for one-to-one online tuition.
After being contacted by a frustrated chemistry teacher whose students were copying ideas from this list to use as their IAs, I am adding the following disclaimer:
Remember also that ‘Personal Engagement’ is one of your assessment criteria, so again, don’t just copy one of these ideas!
The links are to sites or documents that give more information about the practical procedures involved.
We store some data to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with this. You can learn more here
Dear Carl,
After attending an IB workshop this summer specifically focusing on the IA, I wanted to share a piece of information that I learned that unfortunately affects most of your suggestions above. Since this was a workshop sponsored by the IB, the information is relevant and accurate.
IA reports, which focus on the comparison of brands or types of foods (1. Vitamin C content of ‘superfoods’ – Use redox titration to find out if superfoods like kale and broccoli contain more vitamin C than oranges and peppers) are not encouraged. Some of your suggestioninclude this type of investigation and while it is not "terrible, there is a better choice. For example, the vitamin C you suggest could be altered to, for example, focus on one type of vitamin C tablet and then comparing how temperature affects the titration, different concentrations of the titrant affect the concentration etc.
Kind regards
Mary Andrews
UNIS
NY NY
Hello Mary,
Thanks for your comment.
Whilst it's a bit of an exaggeration to say that "most" of the suggested ideas are of this type, you are indeed correct that "brand comparison" projects fall foul of the IB's guidelines for all science IAs, which clearly state:
'The straightforward comparison of two organisms or “brands” probably represents a weak RQ since the underlying cause of any difference does not arise from any scientific principle.'
There are also suggestions in the list that would be unsuitable for other reasons; some amount to little more than analytical chemistry projects as they lack the essential element of investigation and challenge.
However, I did not intend this to be a list of 'off-the-shelf' IAs to be taken and copied, which would be both unethical and contrary to the spirit of the IA. Hopefully, the disclaimer that precedes the list makes that clear. It should be taken as a source of ideas that show different ways to connect the IB chemistry syllabus to everyday situations, aimed squarely at a student who is stuck for ideas.
Taking one of these ideas as a starting point and honing it to generate a fit-for-purpose RQ (as you've done with the vitamin C project), with the IA criteria firmly in mind, is I think a good exercise for the student. That was really my intention for this article.
Carl
You mentioned that in the IB guidelines for the IA, "The straightforward comparison of two organisms or “brands” probably represents a weak RQ since the underlying cause of any difference does not arise from any scientific principle."
Unfortunately, I am student whose research question involves comparison between different brands. Is it possible to share the document that states the above (as I couldn't find it) so that I can prove to my teacher that my current research question is not suitable for an IA? Thank you!
Hi Phoebe,
The document containing those guidelines is not publicly available, so unfortunately I can't share it. However, even if your teacher is not aware of these guidelines (which would surprise me), they will be aware of the criteria for a strong RQ and should be able to help you develop your idea into a more robust RQ.
What you should bear in mind is that a good RQ will describe a measurable, quantifiable independent variable (IV) and relate it to a measurable, quantifiable dependent variable (DV) in a very focused and specific way. The problem with 'comparison' projects is that the IV is seldom measurable or quantifiable. For instance, to take one from the list above:
"Use redox titration to find out if superfoods like kale and broccoli contain more vitamin C than oranges and peppers"
the IV is simply types of food that the researcher is changing. It's not measurable or quantifiable. To improve it, you could specifically investigate an IV such as cooking temperature (e.g. "Does cooking temperature affect the levels of vitamin C released from different superfoods measuring using redox titration?"), or water acidity, or water hardness etc.
Also, note the use of the word "probably" in the guidelines - it is possible to conduct an interesting and valid IA involving comparisons.